Ordained Priest | Years | Name | Current Title |
| Most Senior |
| 26 May 1956 |
| Adam Joseph Cardinal Maida | Archbishop Emeritus of Detroit, Michigan, USA |
| 20 Dec 1959 |
| Archbishop Gilbert Marie Michel Méranville | Archbishop Emeritus of Fort-de-France (e Saint Pierre), Martinique |
| 11 Jun 1960 |
| Archbishop Eugenio Sbarbaro | Apostolic Nuncio |
| 9 Jul 1961 |
| Manuel Cardinal Monteiro de Castro | Major Penitentiary Emeritus of the Apostolic Penitentiary, Roman Curia |
| 19 Mar 1966 |
| Archbishop Giacinto Berloco | Apostolic Nuncio |
| 11 Mar 1967 |
| Bishop Robert Joseph Kurtz, C. R. | Bishop Emeritus of Hamilton in Bermuda |
| 25 May 1967 |
| Bishop Michel Marie Jacques Dubost, C.I.M. | Bishop Emeritus of Evry-Corbeil-Essonnes, France |
| 14 Jul 1968 |
| Archbishop Joseph Everard Harris, C.S.Sp. | Archbishop Emeritus of Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago |
| 2 Aug 1970 |
| Bishop Emmanuel Marie Philippe Louis Lafont | Bishop Emeritus of Cayenne (Cajenna), French Guyana |
| 12 Aug 1970 |
| Archbishop Charles Henry Dufour | Archbishop Emeritus of Kingston in Jamaica |
| 3 Jan 1971 |
| Archbishop Donald James Reece | Archbishop Emeritus of Kingston in Jamaica |
| 27 Jun 1971 |
| Archbishop Robert Rivas, O.P. | Archbishop Emeritus of Castries, Saint Lucia |
| Most Junior |
| 27 Jun 2004 |
| Bishop Philippe Médard Guiougou | Bishop of Basse-Terre (et Pointe-ŕ-Pitre), Guadeloupe |
| 11 Jun 2002 |
| Bishop Kendrick John Forbes | Bishop of Roseau, Dominica |
| 23 Jun 2001 |
| Archbishop David Thomas Daniel Macaire, O.P. | Archbishop of Fort-de-France (e Saint Pierre), Martinique |
| 21 Jan 1996 |
| Bishop Gerard Maximin County, C.S.Sp. | Bishop of Kingstown, Saint Vincent and Grenadines |
| 18 May 1995 |
| Bishop Neil Sebastian Ricardo Scantlebury | Bishop of Bridgetown, Barbados |
| 17 Apr 1993 |
| Bishop Christopher John Glancy, C.S.V. | Auxiliary Bishop Emeritus of Belize City-Belmopan, Belize |
| 27 Dec 1992 |
| Bishop Alain René Ransay | Bishop of Cayenne (Cajenna), French Guyana |
| 23 Jun 1991 |
| Bishop Burchell Alexander McPherson | Bishop Emeritus of Montego Bay, Jamaica |
| 23 Jun 1991 |
| Bishop Robert Anthony Llanos | Bishop of Saint John’s-Basseterre, Virgin Islands (British) |
| 19 Mar 1991 |
| Archbishop Charles Jason Gordon | Archbishop of Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago |
| 19 May 1990 |
| Bishop Wiesław Śpiewak, C. R. | Bishop of Hamilton in Bermuda |
| 27 May 1989 |
| Archbishop Santiago De Wit Guzmán | Apostolic Nuncio to Trinidad and Tobago |